• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer

221 JOHN ST • CLAYTON, NY 13624 • (315) 686-3111

1 MARKET ST • ALEXANDRIA BAY, NY 13607 • (315) 482-3002

Cerow Agency | Clayton NY

Cerow Agency | Clayton NY

Cerow Agency, Inc. is the time tested solutions to all your insurance needs.

  • HOME
  • PRODUCTS & SERVICES
  • CARRIERS
  • HISTORY
  • STAFF
  • DEFENSIVE DRIVING
  • EMAIL

CARRIERS

A Partial List of the Companies We Represent

Preferred Mutual:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 800-333-7642

Main Street America Group/National Grange:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 877-425-2467

New York Central Mutual:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 888-234-6926

Hanover:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 800-628-0250

Philadelphia:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 800-765-9749

OneBeacon:
24 Hour Claim Service Call
877-248-3455 (Commercial Claims)

Progressive:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 800-776-4737

Michigan Millers Mutual:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 800-888-1914 or 888-737-8256

National General:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 877-468-3466

Travelers: 
24 Hour Claim Service Call 800-842-6812

Erie & Niagara
24 Hour Claim Service Call 866-587-9820

Foremost:
24 Hour Claim Service Call 800-527-3907

Midstate Mutual:
800-826-8520 (During Business Hours)

CNA Surety

AmTrust Financial
24 Hour Claim Service Call 866-272-9267

ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company
24 Hour Claim Service Call 800-365-4999

Dryden Mutual:
24 Hour Claim Service:
800-782-0154 (days)  800-556-5802 (nights & weekends)

Leatherstocking Insurance Co
24 Hour Claim Service Call 607-282-4801

Oswego County Mutual Insurance
24 Hour Claim Service Call 315-625-7065

American Modern Insurance Co

Selective Insurance Company of America:
24 Hour Claim Service: 1-866-455-9969

Nationwide Insurance
24 Hour Claim Service:
877-669-6877

Claims Information:

Most claims can be initiated by calling the agency during regular business hours, when our staff can give you the personalized service you need after sustaining a loss.

Regular Business Hours Call:

Clayton: 315-686-3111
Alexandria Bay: 315-482-3002

Some of our insurance companies prefer that you contact them directly to report the loss, so they can assign an adjuster immediately and then confirm with us the information you provided. This is especially helpful after hours, if you need 24 hour claims service.

Please refer to our list of insurance companies and related website links and phone numbers to report a claim directly. Have your policy number ready, and remember feel free to call the agency if you have any questions at all or want to talk to someone you know. We’re here to help!

A Member of SANNY Representing these fine insurance carriers:

CNA
Chubb
Hartford
Utica National
Zurich
Tower
Liberty Mutual

Andover
Firemans Fund/McGee
Encompass
Kemper
Merchants Mutual
Vermont Mutual
Mercury Insurance

STOP IN OR CALL OUR OFFICE
FOR A FREE QUOTE

Our staff will find you the best solution to meet your needs!

EMAIL US

CLAYTON

221 John Street
Clayton, NY 13624

Phone: (315) 686-3111
Fax: (315) 686-3596

ALEXANDRIA BAY

1 Market Street
Alexandria Bay, NY 13607

Phone: (315) 482-3002
Fax: (315) 482-3010

NAVIGATION

  • HOME
  • PRODUCTS & SERVICES
  • CARRIERS
  • HISTORY
  • STAFF
  • DEFENSIVE DRIVING
  • EMAIL

Copyright © 2025 · Cerow Agency | Clayton NY · All Rights Reserved · Privacy Policy · Cyber Policy · Powered by Riverside Media, LLC

Return to top